10.16.2007

HTT - L&D Edition


In my lifetime, I’ve only seen one baby be born ... and it wasn’t Miss Dub.

I mean, I was most certainly in the same room when she made her big debut, but I was on the other side of the action, if you know what I’m sayin’.

The baby I saw enter this world was the firstborn of my dear friendsista, Gfunk, who is now the proud mother of FIVE – and an amazing receptacle of pop culture knowledge and urban street smarts.

I must brag that I was the sole “sister” in the delivery room that day, along with Glamma Fabulous, though her sisters have made up for that day by being at the subsequent births of her children.

In fact, it’s pretty much a party in Gfunk’s hospital room when it comes time for delivery. The more, the merrier, in her opinion. And I’m glad she feels that way because seeing Son X make his way into the world was such a sweet, memorable experience for me, even if he is now seven and would probably kick me in the shins if I ever tried to hug him.

On the other hand, only Mr. Dub and every medical resident in the greater Chicago area were on hand for Miss Dub’s delivery. Since my mom was all the way out in Arizona, I decided to have her come out after I was back from the hospital rather than try to fly her in last minute. I wouldn’t have minded her being there, but I wasn’t devastated by her absence either. And while I would have reciprocated for Gfunk or Mrs. Jay, I pretty much don’t plan on inviting my friends and/or mailmen into the room in the future, mostly because those rooms are really small and labor is pretty boring.

Other people I know are even more adamant about NOT having anyone there. No mothers. No outsiders. Maybe not even their husbands.

And while I will fight to the death to preserve a laboring woman’s right to anydarnthingshewants, I wonder if their motivation is to have a more intimate experience or worries about someone seeing their hoo-hoo. And if it’s the latter, I say, “Hey! As long as the doc has taken a peek, who cares?”

And what about your other children? Is it cool or not to let them be there for the baby’s first moments of life? I hadn’t thought about this much until a friend brought up the Hot Topic. I’m thinking it’s a bad idea only because small children can be really annoying, especially after you’ve been pushing for two hours. But, then again, it is a miracle worth witnessing at some point in your life.

Soooo ... what’s your delivery room like? A public party or a private engagement only?

And if you haven’t been on the other side of the stirrups, how do you feel about being in the room for someone else’s labor and delivery?

Go.

38 comments:

anna said...

I saw my youngest sister born when I was 12. It was really amazing to be there to hold her as soon as she came out (and got cleaned up), but I have to say I thought labor and delivery was pretty gross for a long time. Okay, I still think it's gross, but I now think it's a miracle as well.

As for my own labor and delivery - I was adamant about it being just me and my husband, and the nurse and midwife. I decided to do it naturally and it was an incredible experience (probably another HTT). I knew that my mom would be kind of a dominant presence in the room and didn't really want to share the miraculous and sweet experience with anyone but our little family for a little while.

My cousin was the opposite extreme and I am pretty sure she sent out formal invitations to every pregnancy and delivery moment, including her ultrasounds. That's sharing a little too much, if you ask me.

Rachie said...

I was in the room for the birth of my nephew. It was incredible! I loved it because I was not the one pushing a baby out.

When I had the twins, it was me, Ryan, 2 doctors (one for each baby), and a few medical students. We were in a special delivery room for preemies so our parents were not allowed. I LOVED giving birth. It was fast and easy.

In the future I think I would be fine with the moms and sisters being there. But no boys...

doezie10 said...

When I had my first baby, I invited my Mom, oldest sis(she filmed the birth)my neice(who is also my best friend, we're also the same age...my other best friend at the time, my sister in law, I think that's all for that one. I didn't have a husband to be there for me so it worked out well...
So for my next baby, I had a DH-Yea! We invited both our Mothers, my neice/best friend(she filmed this time, my DH sister, and our darling girls.(My DH had two daughters from a previous marriage) Yes we let our other children watch and it was AWESOME! They loved it! I remember looking straight ahead as I pushed, and all three girls mouths were literally on the floor! They got to see their baby brother born! They also got to see first hand what happens to you when you have sex! It was a great lesson for them!

Heather said...

For my own labors I'm pretty adamant that it's just my husband and I. I enjoyed the hours we spent together before they make their debut.

I was in the room to witness the birth of my neice. I swore that I would NEVER be in the room with anyone else but in a last minute decision, I was. My sister's husband doesn't really do L&D (he stands near the corner of the room, facing the opposite direction of his wife)so when it suddently was time to push the nurse said to my other sister and I "ok gals take a leg" we looked at eachother with shock in our eyes. It wasn't bad at all except my sister kept apologizing A.)for not having shaved better and B.) for the fact that we saw her hoo-hoo. It was funny. I'm glad I was there.

But as for me and my hoo-hoo, we will deliver babies without an audience.

Anonymous said...

I have 5 kids and usually only have the docs and my husband there. Although when my first born was born and I was deep in the thros of "natural childbirth" and just about ready to push, the nurse came in and said, "There's a lady out in the hallway and she wants to know if she can watch." A complete stranger. Obviously my brain was overcome with the INTENSE pain and I said, "whatever!" So the complete stranger lady came in watched the entire thing, took some pictures for us and then dissapeared, completely, forever. Hey, do the 3 nephites have a sister?

emily said...

Alls I know is that my husband is pretty darn worthless in the L&D room. You gotta love him, but he's always on the verge of passing out and stealing all the attention. It's MY time buddy! So this last time I delivered naturally and had one of the girls in the ward (who had coached a few other moms) be my doula. It was the best, she gave me the attention I needed and hubby just stood back and operated the camera. I know it's not for everyone, but worked for me!

Ashby said...

I had never been present at the birth of a baby, so my sister invited me to film the birth of my nephew. I am not a blood and guts type of gal, I get weak in the knees when I see blood from a papercut. And I don't think it helped that I was 6 months pregnant myself and realizing I was about to go through the same thing. But like you said, it is totally different when it is you going through it. I already had one of my own, and amid all the pushing and breath holding during her birth I don't ever remember having the overwhelming need to pass out. And while I agree that it is an amazing experience to be present a the birth of a baby, it's just not for me. Obviously with my own kids I can't NOT be there. And I'm grateful I had the opportunity to be present during his birth, but as the blood drained from my face and my eyes popped out of my head I realized that I enjoy being at the birth of my own babies, and that's all.

As for people being there, at my first delivery I had my husband, mom, and sister. At the 2nd delivery it was my husband and mom. I am considering just having my husband present from here on out. I loved having family there, but I would really like for it to be a little more private in the future.

acte gratuit said...

When I was 16 or 17 my mom and I went to visit my Sister-in-law in the hospital. First, I watched her get an epidural, she went from moaning in pain, to complete calm and happiness. (I've been an advocate ever since.)

So, I was just hanging out in the room, talking to her, my brother and my mom while she labored. I was pretty sure that when it came time for the actual labor, they'd kick me out. They didn't. My mom was on camera duty and everyone seemed to be relaxed and having a relatively good time.

The doctor came in, there were many contractions that she didn't feel, but still no one told me to leave so I just sat there by the window wondering what was going on. Then everyone started getting pretty excited and my mom started yelling, "Emily! Come SEE THIS! IT'S SUCH A MIRACLE!" I went running over at her command, saw my nephew born, saw the placenta delivered, and went back to my seat by the window.

It was cool and all, but I think I could have waited a few years to see that. Mostly though, the experience just gave me a testimony of epidurals. In fact, I think I'll mention that next Fast Day.

Oh, and yes. Since my mom was holding the camera when she rushed to see "the miracle", they have the whole x-rated incident on tape.

Leslie said...

in brief: no kids, that's just kind of weird. i think coming to the hospital to see new sibling the next day is just fine.
my mom told me she didn't want to see me push a baby out. she did it six times, she didn't want to see me in that kind of pain.
i'm all for husband only. but then i've had three c-sections, so what do i know.

stephanie said...

i have c-sections, so i think i am only allowed to bring my husband with me. that is fine because i think i would only want him with me, anyway. my mom went through labor 6 times herself. i don't think she wants to see any more, so she stays home and takes care of the other kids.

i have never seen a baby being born. in college, i was supposed to watch the miracle of birth movie in one of my classes. but after nearly passing out at the part where they give the lady the epidural with the world's largest needle, i skeedaddled.

stephanie said...

ok, leslie and i are practically the same person. we always comment at the same time and say the exact same thing. it's weird.

emily said...

i just found your blog while surfing and thought this post was an interesting topic! for myself when it gets right down to it ... bring in the circus - just get the baby out! as for my husband ... he's a little more, shall we say, private. he kinda feels like it should be just us - but conceded to having my mom there after i insisted. my brother-in-law is adamant that only those that were there at conception are welcome at delivery.
i think i'd love to be there for the first moments of life for a baby other than my own ... i can think of a few friends that might invite me ... and possibly 1 or 2 of my sisters. i'm not so sure about inviting myself - mmm, how to ask without asking!?
thanks for the great post and hope you don't mind if i come back again - love your writing, you are so eloquent!!

Jen said...

I didn't want to have kids for three weeks after I watched my youngest sibling be born. I was the ripe old age of 18 (Yes, I'm from Utah).

I like a nice intimate birth, but I'd let my kids come because my friend said it made her kids really bonded to each other.

steph said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Lizzie said...

I am pretty much thinking just hubby and me so that it is personal and intimate. But, this may sound weird, I totally would have my father-in-law there. As a doctor and pediatrician I think it would really set my mind at ease to have an advocate like that in the room.

Maybe after our first I would be more open to having other people there!

Lacey said...

There is nothing like giving birth to a little baby. I had everything planned, it would be me, my hubby, our moms and my sister, that was it! I had it all envisioned, planned, and set, and then real life happened. My hubby had to go to a convention for work 2 weeks before I was due. After an okay from the doctor and a promise that I definitely had a good 2 weeks until our little guy would come join us my hubby jumped on an airplane to Florida. Well, our little guy had other plans and I went into labor after my hubby had been gone for less than 24 hours. Before I knew it I was in the hospital with my grandma, mother-in-law, father-in-law, 4 sister-in-laws, 2 brother-in-laws, my mom and sister on the phone as they drove across the country to get to me and my poor hubby on the phone, stuck in the airport. It was a little crazy in the hospital room but I was thankful to have the love and support around me when my husband was so far away. Although the boys left when I was actually giving labor the room was still full when our little boy made his debut. If I would have known before hand how it would all play out I would have laughed and then cried but looking back I wouldn't have had it any other way, except having my hubby THERE. However, I would have to say next time I will keep it a little more low key with a little less drama but it makes for a great story and I really learned what I was made of, if you can have a baby alone, you can do anything!

sara said...

I didn't think I would want my mom to be there for my first baby; I mean she was at the hospital since we were in the same city and all, but once it was really time I'd realized it would be dumb to make her leave the room. I'm glad she was there. So for my two "regular" births my mom & Hubs were both there & that's just how I would do it again. For my c-section it was just Hubs; I wish my mom could've been there just because she's really interested in medical stuff; also because Hubs didn't want to watch during the incision & stuff, and I was hoping someone would give me a play-by-play!

I would never consider having kids witness a birth, or men who are not my doctor or hospital staff.

zeeny said...

My first born was just my husband and I and of course the medical staff. It was nice but I wouldn't have minded my mom being there. She lives across the country and we had to guess on her plan ticket. When my second was born late my mom was here and went to the hospital with me. I loved having her there...it was her first birth besides her own seven children. (Entirely different in my opinion) She was so excited and tried to be as useful as possible. It calmed me a bit just knowing she was there. At one point I was in the bathroom (by myself) going through a contraction and I heard her and my husband talking about how much pain I must be in. (They were whispering) I heard it and wanted to tell them to be quiet but was in too much pain to tell them! I loved having my mom there and figure when I'm in labor I really don't care who sees my whoo hoo! That delivery my doctor wasn't even there and my husband caught my baby by the leg as she flew out of my body...yes flew out! I would let my child come if they were old enough/mature enough. It all depends!

janaya said...

again... no babies yet, so i am not speaking from any experience at all... but i've thought about this. and the only real temptation i have to bring anyone with me other than my husband is to bring my college roommates who can just tell me funny stories and make me laugh when i want to cry. or maybe they can go to the delivery room early and put up handmade signs that say things like "janaya for senior class president" and "janaya for assistant hymnbook coordinator" and "we love janaya"... 'cause it worked in college when i needed a little pick me up... why not in L&D? :)

and i think having my mom (whom i love to death) crying her eyes out in the L&D room with me would just make me crazy... so no moms for me.

and i don't say this word very often... but kids in the delivery room with me... HELL no.

Melanie M. McKinnon said...

i though i wouldn't mind people in the room. but after months on bed rest and being huge and not being able to move my legs, due to the epidural, i changed my mind at the last minute.

my dad ended up delivering my gracie(it's ok, he's a doctor). everyone thinks it's weird but it was the best labor experience i've had: my mom holding my left leg, robby holding my right, dad pulling out the baby, nurse counting in the background.

robby passed out when i was getting my cathater put in. and i've assisted my dad in putting an IV in my dehydtrated mother a hundred times and got pretty woozy. i'm ok not ever seeing an actual birth from someone elses perspective other than the pushing perspective.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for the shout out Mrs. Dub! X loved it too! You are always welcome in the delivery room mi delivery casa es su delivery casa! I do love a good party in and out of the sturups(sp?) and would do it the same way every time.It was a fun and an awe inspiring experience every time (5 stretch mark causing times!).I understand why people want it to be private for several reasons and thats a "to each his own " deal.I adore my Mom and sistahs (blood born or not) and luckily my hub Jerky is a fan too! I dont dig everyone enjoying a full frontal view of my Hoover (upright with attachments) but they've seen the discovery channel so i guess if you've seen one you've seen em' all!
Now for a serious quandry-
To shave or not to shave that is the question!I found myself apologizing to everyone in there for not gettin' a brazilian before the big unveiling - is that crizazy?

Laurel said...

I say bring in the stadium seats...let's get as many people as possible into the L&D room. Just kidding although that is what my friends doctor said when he walked into the L&D and her entire family including her dad and brothers were present.

My DH and mom were there at the birth of Liam (which was wonderful) but I wouldn't mind having my sisters there.

Anonymous said...

I am surprised that people will have kids in the room! No way! I think my girls would be totally freaked out seeing that. I mean, I don't really want to SEE it myself! When I was pushing my first out, they wheeled in a huge mirror for me to see. I took one look and was like, "Ahhh! Get that thing out of here!" I am not prude. But come on, it's not pretty.

I stick with my husband and my mom, who is instructed to stay near my head. I am very close to my sisters, but I like to keep somethings to myself!

Alifinale said...

Right before I had my li'l miss, my sis-in-law had a baby. I asked her if I could be there so I could know what I was headed for (mind you it was her 3rd and she only pushed 1 time so it wasn't an accurate depiction). It ended up being quite the party during her delivery - Hubbie, mom, dad, grandma, grandpa, aunt judy, 2 sis-in-laws and many medical personnel. She was ok with it, but I kept wanting to kick some of the people out.

I was glad that we lived far away for our first child so it could be just my hubbie and I without offending mothers by asking them not to be in the room (that is my mom's biggest wish). It was nice to have that moment with just my hubbie (and the nurse and doctor) for our first child. I think that in the future I wouldn't mind having a mom or sister be there to hold my dead legs - but I definitely don't want every relative there.

As for the other children there...no way. My nephew got inside right after the above spoken delivery and was freaked out by all the blood. I think any child under 16 shouldn't be there and I don't plan on having kids for that long so none of my kids will be there.

Kate said...

My first- my husband and my mom were in the room.. thank goodness for both! I think you need one person to hold your hand or rub your head (my husbands specialty) and one to film or take pictures....(not graphic pics mind you) My second (the same) My third- I literally had a party going on in my room... My dad, dad in law, mom in law, mom, sis in law, and sister (call me crazy) as long as they wanted to watch I was fine with it... My fourth- much the same as my third... I just think it is such a joyous occasion- why not have everyone there...(okay- not everyone!)

liz said...

I've never even considered having anyone but my husband in the delivery room, and no one has ever asked. I think it's just the culture in both of our families to make it a private event, because as far as I know, no one, including sisters, mothers, etc. has ever been invited to any of the births. I would definitely not have children in the room. I'd enjoy visits from fun and supportive people during labor, but peace and quiet for delivery, please.

mommie said...

Back in the "olden days" only dads were allowed. I was quite content with the process and I think PDaddy was too.

I was happy to see you and Mrs. Gee follow suit. I am guessing that will be true for the next ones because I will be at your homes with the first ones.

Having said that ... I know that you, Mrs Dub., loved that experience at X's delivery and I was thrilled you could have it.

Ilene said...

I have done the birthing thing twice. Both times it was only my hubby. Mainly because my mom never made it in town for my delivery (both boys came early). My Mother in Law was there for my first boy's birth but I had her out of the room when things got bad (my epidural wasn't so good that time and I didn't like having her watching me when I was so miserable). The second time only my hubby was around which was a shame because my epidural was a DREAM and I think I would have welcomed the slightest acquaintance into the room with open arms. I still owe that anesthesiologist a big kiss.

I say to each her own. However, the only stinky thing about having only your husband around is if your baby has to be taken to the NICU for observation. Both my boys were taken away from me due to slight breathing problems minutes after birth. Of course I sent my husband to be with them but then I was sitting in the delivery room all by myself. That is depressing. So I say, even if you don't want a party during delivery, try to have someone nearby so you don't have to worry about being alone should something happen.

Leslie said...

back in the really really olden days, when my MIL was having kids in the 60s, dads weren't even allowed. my husband's dad wasn't present for any of his seven children being born. well, he was in the hallway.

Carina said...

The first time it was my husband, my mom and dad. When I called mom and dad to come, I was surprised that dad came into the room, but in the middle of things, shoot, call in the army, I don’t care.

For my second, it was so fast my mom didn’t even make it in time. It was just me, DH, and the midwife. It was great, but honestly, the older I get with more children, the crunchier I get (I don’t understand it myself.) I would absolutely let my older children into the delivery room to see their kids being born. It’s natural for them to see what happens. I think we’re unnecessarily medicalizing birth. It might even be healthy for them to understand consequences; it would definitely be a good deterrent, haha! I don't care if every nursing or medical student is there. I even offered one of my sister's friends, who is a nursing student, access to my L&D. She was too far away when I had my second, but if anyone else wants to come over, I don't care.

DH is a little more staid and reserved; he can barely take being there for me. My dad is my biggest supporter in wanting natural childbirth (my mom and DH think I’m nuts.) I might even get a doula next time and invite my other kids. Just so you know, DH would probably have a conniption. He’s more traditional western medicine 1950-1980 in the way he approaches birth. When I say I’m traditional, I mean bring on the midwife, the natural childbirth, the nursing till they wean, and the baby sling.

When did I get so crunchy??

Kelley Bochman Smith said...

My first daughter (Gfunk) was born 30 years and two days ago. I experienced most of my labor in the hall (by myself) in an overcrowded hospital. My latino girlfriends in the labor rooms were SCREAMING THE EYES OUT while I grew more scared and more lonely. I have experienced all of my 8 grandchildrens births and it is deffinatly much more wonderful! I am so thankful to my daughters and especially my son in laws for asking me to be there. I can understand for a need of privacy for those who want it, but seeing my newborn grandchildren being born was by far the most spiritual, happy, wonderful moments in my life. The kid topic, I wouldn't want to be the Mom, trying not to screem and breath and not cuss!!!!

Colleen said...

To each her own, but I'm not into the whole group birth idea myself. I love my mom dearly, but I don't even have the kind of relationship with her where I'd like her to be there. Just me and DH. I'm a natural birth kinda girl, and I don't need any distractions.

go boo boo said...

I have c-sections too, no one allowed but dh. By the third one, we both watched, one on the side of the curtain and me via the mirror. Pretty freaking surreal.

My sister Katie's birth has been a big ole party since #2. I get a kick out of her father-in-law who is truly right up in there, and not even in any sort of creepy way at all. Thinking of it, he may not have seen any of his own children's births (like my dad) b/c of the generation thing Leslie mentioned.

Third and final - no kids, I think that's too much information.

Great HT.

Morgan said...

i was also in the room when my youngest sister was born, i was in 6th grade. at the last minute, i almost didn't go in cuz i was a little scared by everything that was going on. but i did and it was amazing, and really gross. i remember thinking that i was never going to have kids because of all the nasty stuff that came out. but i got to cut her ambilical cord, and have always thought of her as my little baby.

however, i did not want anyone but me and my hubs in the room. no, not even my mother. i really wanted it to be an intimate experience with just me and him and the baby. i actually found out later, that my mom (who was in town when i went into labor) was on her way out the door to come to the hospital anyway when my husband called to tell her that the baby was born. good thing my labor was so fast! but it really bothered me that she would go against what i wanted and just decide to come anyway without even asking. i think that it is a very personal decision, that for me had nothing to do with anyone seeing my "hoo-hoo".

I haven't decided wether or not to invite her for our second. i think it might hurt her feelings, but i agree that it's all about what the woman pushing the baby out wants!

Holly said...

I have never seen a real live birth, but have seen many-a-home video during my hypnobirthing classes. I have to say that I'm not a big fan of watching it happen.

For me, I prefer just my husband to be in L&D. They were such amazing moments for us that having anyone else in there would have obviously been different and taken away from those intimate moments for us. I am very close with my Mom, but would rather have her afterwards for the help when I am out of the hospital!

Charlotte said...

My last birth I used "hypnobirthing." I'm a HUGE advocate... it was pain free! Less pain than my previous 2 which I had epi's with. Anyway, the best part of it was the amazing bonding experience it was with my husband. Other people were there (my sis and mother-in-law) but we didn't even notice... we were so focused on "our" experience. Previously my husband was a little peeved when others were there, partly because I was such a wreck and he felt useless and others there accentuated that feeling! So I think it all depends on the labor and whats going on. In addition, at my hypnobirthing classes, the midwife advised against having your kids there. It's a very rare person that is able to ignore their young kids and focus on the necessary job at hand.

Laurie said...

I like the intimacy of just me and my husband. With the birth of my son Noah, There was a lot of family tension, my parents divorce was final the day after his birth and my mom kept trying to come into the delivery room. I had instructed my husband and all the nurses that it be just me and my hubby. I was in labor for a total of 30 hours, so some people did come and bring him food. I still think I just want my hubby and me there for this next one in January. Although things are calmed down in the family area.

My baby sister had my mom at her delivery and my mom still gushes about it.

Jack Attack said...

a private affair, just my husband (and doctor, and my nurse and the baby nurse and tech)...that's enough. It was very nice and mellow. We did not have family come until my baby was 3 days old so we had a few days to bond. I think I'll do that for all my kids.
I have no desire to attend any other births than my own, nor will I have my own children present.