Miss Dub is a girl.
And while babies do have an asexual appearance, I don’t think it requires an unveiling of her diaper to determine her gender. Even when she wears blue.
When people ask me this question – about twelve times daily, but who’s counting? – I want to respond with my own questions.
Like, “Do you think her head-to-toe pink ensemble might be a clue?”
Or, “Do you think I would wrap my son’s head with a fat bow?”
Or, “How many freaking times do I have to use a feminine pronoun for you to stop referring to my dearest ‘she’ as a ‘he’?”
It’s not that I haven’t been in the same situation myself as most babies, especially newborns, bear no feminine or masculine qualities to announce their respective chromosome combinations.
And if the baby is sporting a unisex outfit, it’s that much harder. (And don’t even get me started about boys wearing dresses – I’m all for equality, but you’re really making these kinds of questions harder for the rest of us.)
I just make sure to listen, observe and then ask carefully before making gender assumptions. Or trick the mom into revealing it without expressing my ambiguity.
Maybe it’s my bad because I’m not into frilly duds that scream “girl!” to the innocent bystander. And I don’t really do bows that often because:
a. I can’t find cute ones
b. Mr. Dub hates them
c. Miss Dub hates them
d. They make her head all a’sweaty
e. All of the above
(The correct answer is E.)
But despite all my ranting, I really don’t mind giving someone a quick clarification on Miss Dub’s gender when asked. What’s really annoying is when someone defends themselves for calling her a boy.
Like, “Well, why is she wearing red pants?” (Um, I don’t know because I didn’t get the memo that said red is exclusive to boys. Not to mention I paired it with a frilly white sweater.)
Or, “Then why did you give her a boy’s name?” (Um, it’s not. You’re thinking of Aidan.)
Or, “Well she looks like a boy!” (Um, excuse me, I’m about to go Jackie Chan on you!)
So I just wanted you all to know she’s a girl as I’m clearly a little sensitive about the question.
But not as sensitive as I was about some other questions, like:
“Are you due any day now?” … when I was only 5 months along.
Or, “Did you really want a boy?” … when I told people I was expecting a girl.
Or, “Are you planning to breastfeed?” … when I was pregnant. (Because although I do breastfeed, I still find that question a bit too personal for chatting with strangers over Costco’s salmon selection.)
What are the most annoying questions people ask you, mothers or not?
And if you are a mom … don’t you wish you could have just handed them this ?
7.06.2007
"Is he a girl?"
Posted by Mrs. Dub at 7:50 AM
23 comments Leave a witty comment hereLabels: Miss Dub, motherhood, musing, Parent Bloggers Network
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)





- acte gratuit
- barefoot in the kitchen
- brooke a la mode
- coast 2 coast
- collecting crust
- flowerchain
- glamma fabulous
- good sons
- la dolce vespa
- la vida steffa
- livin' in the 'copa
- living with the lens cap on
- mrs. dub reviews
- simplehappy home
- jackson 5.0
- the devz
- the r house
- this girl's life
- welcome to haggartown

- a room somewhere
- a unique snowflake
- brookie b.
- elephant droppings
- eli love
- eriksens
- garner family
- happy life
- here kitschy kitschy
- horstmann happenings
- janni, marvin & luke
- life through our eyes
- little bit of gracie lue
- little miss sassy pants
- loco lunds
- michigan bliss
- pictures of me
- ramblings
- the devlins
- the harkers
- the kamae ohana
- the new news
- the parmas
- the real rachel ray
- the rogers
- young family

- 2 boys & a mommy
- a little sussy
- a moment in time
- a of all
- a perfect 10
- according to alice
- according to kelly
- alice's adventures
- alifinale
- best of the bunch
- blog con queso
- bougainvillea
- cjane enjoy it
- cole fam
- confessions of a rookie
- cool mom picks
- design mom
- emily anne
- funny madre
- green bean ruminations
- grow old with you
- heather bailey
- hilary's happiness
- holly rambling
- idaho laytons
- it's a wonderful life
- jack attack
- la vie est belle
- layton life
- live, love, laugh
- liz
- loudaisy
- mamablogues
- mrs. bennett
- my happy little life
- my kid rocks!
- oh happy day
- olson fam
- our family garden
- pioneer woman
- rowena's rantings
- sibling revelry
- simmons fam
- snakes, snails and tails
- the jet set
- the meegans
- the typical family
- the warehouse
- wonderland girl

23 comments:
The "is he a girl" question can get downright ridiculous. No one ever mistook my boy for a girl, but one Target checker (think SNL) would have looked passed ribbons, pearls, sequins and a big sparkly banner reading "I AM A GIRL" and still said about my daughter "Aww, isn't HE cute?"
Ashamedly, I admit though that I have sometimes been on the giving end of such errors. Now, if I'm not sure (and certainly there are those cases) I just say "your BABY is so cute, HOW OLD?" and wait for the mother to use the proper pronoun.
I have to admit >< I once called a little 8 year old girl a boy! eeeeek! But you have to understand, she had a bowl cut hair-do and she wore boy clothes! Her mother did say that they get it ALL the time and that she was more comfortable dressing like a little boy... let me just tell you, i was SUPER embarrassed and since then I never assume anything!
When I was a substitute teacher, I once mistook a twelve-year-old male student for a girl. He was very petite for his age, had a sweet voice and a friendly substitute-helper's attitude, and although he was wearing oversized sports-jersey type clothes, they were in pastel colors--the kind all the girls were wearing. Finally, he was sporting the unisex hairdo of choice at that school--cornrows (it was the Iverson era)--but they had sparkly beads and stuff on them. At that age, it's so much worse to mistake a boy for a girl than vice versa, and he was just crushed and I almost cried I felt so bad. And now I'm reliving it. Thanks, Mrs. Dub.
Oh my God, I got this all the time with Lady. She had NO HAIR. None. So people just assumed. And with the red? Forget it. They were positive she was a boy.
Now, on the other hand, I've had people declare the minute they lay eyes on Mister that he is ALL BOY. I'm not entirely sure how to take this, I guess I'm happy they think so, but honestly? I don't need their confirmation.
Most STUPID thing people have asked me: "Are they twins?" WHAT???
Although I have been told that my boys look alike (I don't think so), they are 2.5 years apart in age and size. Not like I have a dainty 5-yr-old and a giant almost-3-yr-old. It's not really annoying... just funny.
As for the gender issue, my boys have never been mistaken for girls. I know Jamie has commented before about how OFTEN this has happened with her. Particularly because her little ladies don't grow much hair.
Soooo, I'm totally curious to see what will happen when my little gal comes along in September. I'm sure she'll have lots of hair soon (we're quite hairy in this house)... and I'll have to put it in bows and things... but I am also sure I will be VERY defensive if anyone ever calls her a boy.
A brief rundown of our family- 2 kids from my husband's 1st marriage (boy & girl), and then 3 boys. We are done.
When we found out that our last baby was a boy, people said things like this- "I'm sorry. I'm sure you wanted a girl." and "So even though you said this was your last one, will you try again for a girl?" AND even "I'm sorry."
And I wanted to say, I'm sorry you are so dumb.
Because before we got pregnant with our last one, we knew (or at least we felt strongly) that there was one more boy for our family. And we weren't disappointed ONE TINY bit with him!
My daughter had abnormally giant cheeks when she was a baby...and people would always say, "What are you feeding that thing?" Thing?? She's a baby! And need we point out that she looks like an overfed beast rather than a chubby staged baby?
I have three girls, ages 5, 3, and 1. As my big sis mentioned, I have gotten a lot of the "Isn't HE cute?" comments and questions in the past. There are two questions that I get almost anytime I go out with my girls. They are, "Are they all yours?" I mean, I have only 3 kids here, people. Not 16, in which case I would expect that question. But does 3 seem like some huge number where people have to ask if they are mine? Sometimes I want to say, "No. I picked this baby up in the parking lot." The other question is always, "Are you going to try for a boy?" Yeah, cause that is your business, Mr. Stranger. Oh, and I also get a lot of, "Your poor husband. He must be going crazy with SO many girls." I ALWAYS tell them that he LOVES having girls and doesn't really want a boy now!
This happens to me ALL the time, even when Skylar is dressed in all pink, bow on head, and she has her ears pierced! I guess the lack of hair is what gets people. It drives me crazy but I just try to be polite and correct them as nonchalantly as possible :)
(edit: passed? what does passed mean? is that even a word? i meant past. i have sick kids here, i'm tired. i am educated. really.)
Leisha... I think you were right the first time. Passed is a word... like, "I passed up a really good lunch date today to read blogs instead!"
past: gone by just before the present time; just passed
passed: To go by without paying attention to; disregard or ignore
It's happened to me, many a time... I can echo all previous comments, and I'll leave it at that! It DOESN'T Help that that don't have much hair!
thanks mandee... i have no idea at this point. i'm taking a nap.
Just a quick question: Where did you get your super cute swimsuit top in the post below? I have been searching and searching for something cute that will also hide the baby love... no luck yet. Help? :)
the funny part is we just got back from the pool where a girl said, "he's so cute!" in reference to a leopard-tankini'd miss dub. maybe it's a pronoun slip-up?
as for my swimsuit top, it was a total target find. (possibly on clearance, so good luck!) i paired it with non-matching black polka dot ruffle-trimmed bottoms to complete the coverage. i will say it's far more flattering and modest than the fancy "modest" swimsuits all the rage online. hope you can find it!
I have three boys who were often mistaken for girls, though I promise they were never dressed like girls. I think it was their long eyelashes? I just figured they were so pretty, people were confused, and took it as a compliment. I've also gotten "are they twins?" for the oldest two, who are 2 1/2 years and a full head apart. Whatever. When we had a girl last year, people constantly said "oh, you finally got your girl," as if we were going to just keep going until the XX chromosome won out -- how many babies would we have had before we gave up? 6 boys? 8? 10? By, the way, we may not be done, so I guess it wasn't really about the girl, was it?
We have three boys and a baby girl, so like some previous posters, I was often asked, "Are you going to try for a girl?" Or while I was pregnant with Ruby, "I bet you're hoping for a girl, right?" And now that she's here, "Oh, you finally got your girl." What??? I love boys. In fact, my one-time plan was to have 7 boys and finish up with a girl so she wouldn't be too "girly." I'm thrilled to have Ruby, but I'm thrilled to have all my kids - boys or girls.
People frequently referred to my oldest boy as "she." Then the first time I took Ruby to the Dr., a lady asked, "How old is HE?" Argh!
With children 5, 3, 2, and 6 months, we also get the question, "Are they ALL yours?" Recently, a woman at Burger King asked how old my kids were, and then asked how old I am! What?
Why do people feel so comfortable asking things like that? It doesn't offend me really, I just can't imagine asking a complete stranger things like that.
BTW, Miss Dub is a beautiful little girl - not that you needed that confirmation. :)
the question i'm most often asked as i tote my three adorable kids around is, "are they all yours?" but that's because i can easily be mistaken for either their nanny, or as someone in hawaii suggested, their big sister.
that's okay, though. i'd rather look young than old.
the nurse at my pediatrician always calls miles "she" (and she does see him without a diaper). but i attribute that to the fact that she hails from some cool caribbean island and so her english pronouns are a little mixed up. :)
Hmm, well, this isn't about mistaking a girl for a boy, but my favorite was when the saleslady at my door asked me if I was due any day... WHEN I WAS 4 MONTHS ALONG!!!!! When I told her, no, I wasn't due for another five months she asked me if I was having twins. Needless to say I did not buy what she was selling that day.
She is a beautiful daughter. :)
i have to tell your swimsuit looking people that i found the cutest one piece (which i haven't owned since the tankini arrived) at old navy. it is a black halter and it totally sucks me in--in all the right places.
i love it when people ask, "did he come out of your body?" after i tell them that yes this is my baby, re-assure them a few times and then they go straight for the birthing question.
i haven't had anyone ask me if tyson was a girl, but i did hate it when people asked me why i hadn't started my family yet and when i was going to get pregnant. none of your business! going straight to the sterility part usually shut them up.
I've had random strangers ask if I had an episiotomy. what the PERSONAL!?
miss dub definitely looks like a girl to me. and red is ok for anyone! I think a lot of times people just say he or she based on their own kids or grandkids. but it is annoying. AT LEAST LOOK AT THE OUTFIT/ACCESSORIES BEFORE YOU USE A POSSIBLY-OFFENSIVE PRONOUN, people!
Proximo was wearing this gender-neutral number in overall form when he was last mistaken for a girl. I mean, I guess the red has faded and it looks a little more fuchsia...no it doesn't! It looks RED. Whatever. He's pretty like a girl.
I love being told that I have my hands full. I have two kids, not ten. Do I look incapable?
Post a Comment